A Food Lover’s Guide to Florida Keys Restaurants and Local Dishes

lobster tails

The Florida Keys are renowned for their stunning natural beauty and enticing turquoise waters, inviting visitors from around the world to experience and indulge in an unforgettable tropical adventure. What may be an unexpected, yet equally delightful discovery for many, is the incredible culinary scene that offers an impressive selection of tantalizing local dishes, exciting flavors, and world-class dining experiences to satiate the cravings of any discerning food enthusiast.

In this comprehensive food lover’s guide, we will guide you on a mouthwatering journey through the Florida Keys, exploring the region’s rich culinary traditions, exceptional eateries, and must-try dishes that pay homage to the bountiful ocean and vibrant local culture. As you enjoy your stay at a Florida Keys Vacation Rentals, Inc. vacation home, prepare to treat your taste buds to a vast array of distinctive culinary delights that draw on the influence of Caribbean, Latin, and Southern American cuisines.

A Storied Past: Celebrating the Legends and Icons of the Keys

Delve into the fascinating tales of the Florida Keys, learning about influential figures, sunken treasures, and pivotal events that have shaped the islands. Discover personal haunts of literary greats, explore the remnants of salvaged shipwrecks, and examine the innovative conservation efforts preserving the Keys’ rich history and heritage.

Ernest Hemingway’s Key West

Embark on a journey through Ernest Hemingway’s Key West, as you visit his former home turned museum. The legendary author’s residence, now the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, offers fascinating insights into his life, including Hemingway’s love for the island, his passion for sportfishing, and his world-renowned novels inspired by life in the Keys.

Truman’s Little White House

Experience the historic retreat of President Harry S. Truman as you tour the peaceful Truman’s Little White House. This Presidential sanctuary has played host to multiple leaders, including Truman, Eisenhower, and Kennedy, providing a glimpse into the storied past and important decisions that have taken place within its walls.

Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys

Unearth the captivating history of shipwrecks and salvaging efforts throughout the Florida Keys by visiting the Mel Fisher Maritime Museum. Explore the thrilling stories of sunken treasures, artifacts, and recovery expeditions, as well as the fearless adventurers who risked it all in pursuit of fortune and fame.

Historic Lighthouses: Guiding Lights of the Florida Keys

Discover the vital role and fascinating history of lighthouses scattered throughout the Florida Keys, which have long served as guardians of the treacherous waters and a beacon of hope for mariners navigating the islands. Immerse yourself in these towering structures’ tales of the past, from shipwrecks and adversity to the enduring legacy of brave lightkeepers.

Exploring the Islands’ Cultural Tapestry

Celebrate the diverse cultural fabric of the Florida Keys, as you uncover the islands’ unique blend of Spanish, Bahamian, and Afro-Caribbean heritage.

Influence of Pirate Lore

Engage with the vivid tales and seafaring legends of the Florida Keys, as you learn about pirates who once frequented these waters. Delve into the daring tales of historical figures such as Black Caesar and Captain Kidd, and explore the influence of pirate lore on the spirit and culture of the Keys.

Conch Republic: Independence and Spirit

Examine the tongue-in-cheek secession of the Conch Republic, a quintessential representation of the Florida Keys’ independent nature. Celebrate this light-hearted nod to the island chain’s fierce spirit and determination, just as the locals do during the annual Conch Republic Independence Celebration.

Afro-Caribbean Melting Pot

Discover the rich Afro-Caribbean influence on the Florida Keys, where immigrant populations from the Caribbean islands have left an indelible mark on the region’s history. Explore the African Cemetery at Higgs Beach, which honors the memory of those who lost their lives in the Middle Passage, or visit the Bahama Village neighborhood in Key West to experience vibrant culture, cuisine, and traditions.

Preserve and Protect: Safeguarding the Heritage of the Florida Keys

Learn about the crucial efforts to conserve the Florida Keys’ historical and cultural landmarks, ensuring future generations can partake in these islands’ rich legacy.

Local Restoration Initiatives

Discover the countless ways local organizations such as the Florida Keys National Register of Historic Places and the Florida Keys History & Discovery Foundation work tirelessly to preserve historic properties, museums, and other cultural landmarks throughout the islands.

Conservation Through Education

Take part in the ongoing mission to educate visitors about the importance of preserving the Keys’ unique heritage, by engaging with interactive exhibits at local museums and historical sites, which aim to inspire a deeper understanding and appreciation of the region’s past.

Monroe County Historical Society: Champions of History

Explore the crucial role of the Monroe County Historical Society, which has worked for decades to protect and preserve historical structures and landmarks in the Florida Keys. By engaging the community and advancing historical awareness, the organization plays an integral role in preserving the islands’ cultural fabric.


Immerse yourself in the historical wonders of the Florida Keys while staying at Florida Keys Vacation Rentals, Inc., retracing the footsteps of brave pioneers, legendary authors, and intrepid treasure hunters, whose stories have become woven into the fabric of these idyllic islands. As you navigate from Key Largo to Key West, the Florida Keys reveal fascinating tales of courage, resilience, and determination, inviting you to embrace their vibrant and storied past. By internalizing and sharing the islands’ history and culture, you become part of the ongoing effort to preserve and celebrate the rich heritage of this unique and captivating destination. Browse through our selection of Florida Keys home rentals now.